Bake Better with Butterfinger Select from the options below. All Featured Brownies Cakes Cookies Cupcakes Pies Snacks AllFeaturedBrowniesCakesCookiesCupcakesPiesSnacks Hellmann's Butterfinger Crispety Crunchety Cake Made with real ingredients like eggs and oil, mayonnaise adds moistness and richness to your baking. 30 Minutes Butterfinger Easter Cookie Cups by britney breaksbread Butterfinger Scotcheroos by mikebakesnyc Yields: 12 bars 5 Minutes Butterfinger Oat Bars by Bakers Royale_Naomi Butterfinger x Moments of Sugar Lunar New Year Recipe: Peanut Cookies with Butterfinger Butterfinger Torte by Bakers Royale_Naomi Makes 9 individual cakes 30 Minutes Butterfinger Eggnog Trifles by britney breaksbread Chocolate Dipped Peanut Butter Butterfinger Cookies by mikebakesnyc Makes 12-14 cookies 10 Minutes Butterfinger Shortbread Cookies by Bakers Royale_Naomi Makes 30 cookies 17 Minutes Butterfinger Brownie Truffles Makes 20 truffles Butterfinger Bundt Cake Servings: 12 Chocolate Covered Butterfinger Churros By britneybreaksbread 40 minutes Load More
Hellmann's Butterfinger Crispety Crunchety Cake Made with real ingredients like eggs and oil, mayonnaise adds moistness and richness to your baking. 30 Minutes
